Silicon Valley Moms Book Club Discussion: Testimony, by Anita Shreve
I can't recall having read a book in which I was so glad that I was not
at all similar to any of the characters. Anita Shreve's characters in
Testimony are so deeply imperfect and flawed that they are actually
quite real and rather human. Multiple times I was screaming in my head "No! Don't do it! Don't have that affair/don't say that/don't go there." And of course, the character proceeded to create a storm of trouble and conflict.
Let
me back up a bit; I loved this story. The plot was amazingly rich and
realistic. I could have been reading this story in a newspaper it was
so modern and real. The characters were diverse and hearing their
individual voices gave the story the depth it needed to be taken
seriously. I like that the story discussed the issues of teenage
drinking in the ways that a few different characters consumed alcohol.
Sienna reportedly drank a lot, often. Silas only turned to alcohol
after the shock of finding his mother having an affair, using alcohol
to escape and self medicate only one time, but that one time was enough
for tragedy.
As the child of a parent who was a law enforcement officer (oh
heck, my mommy was/is a cop!) you grow up learning to question even
the victim of an event because it is important to get all sides before
making a judgment or decision about blame, responsibility or
punishment. It is made clear to the reader from the perspective of Rob
Leicht and Laura, Sienna's roommate that she was overly and often
inappropriately physical with people, dressed in a seductive and
possibly slutty manner and thrived on the attention of young boys. She
also drank heavily. Also, she was only fourteen years old. Her
credibility and integrity were questioned by those who came into contact
with her even before the scandal.
I really like the notion that a chain of unlikely events can be
set in motion with one single decision made in an instant and can have
persistent and negative consequences on many lives for a long time. It
is an interesting thing to ponder that all of us in this world are
somehow responsible for each other and can somehow indirectly shape the
life of someone else without any malicious intention or thought.
Shreve really hit it out of the park with Testimony. Plot. Suspence. Death. Sex. Videotapes. Alcohol. Teens. Scandals. Blame. Affairs. This story has many dimensions of intrigue. The potential reality of this story made it a real page-turner.